It does not have to be a either or situation where you are being either satisfied emotionally or being satisfied physically.
Dating a guy not physically attracted to
If youre not attracted to this person now, can you see your attraction to them growing in the future?
Dating a guy you're not physically attracted to
If he was perfect in every way but you just werent physically attracted to him?
If a person is very physically fit, it may show you that they are committed to taking care of their body and can someday commit to taking care of you.
Before you totally kick your current friend to the curb, try to figure out why you are not physically attracted to him.
May be shutting yourself off from being attracted to people who dont meet your intense qualifications.
Someone feels comfortable wearing casual clothes but you are attracted to people that dress in formal wear, then you shouldnt ask them to change their style to fit your preference.